136 East Market Street    |    Sandusky, OH 44870

136 East Market Street  Sandusky, OH 44870

Sweet Popcorn

for Every Sweet Tooth in North-Central Ohio

Bay Popcorn Company, LLC, is the Destination for Sweet Popcorn

No one can stop at just one piece – or even one handful – of amazingly delicious sweet popcorn. And no one does sweet popcorn better in North-Central Ohio than Bay Popcorn Company, LLC, in Sandusky, OH. We are the sweet popcorn authorities, offering a wide variety of flavors to suit even the most particular of tastes. From Sandusky, OH, to Fremont, OH; Norwalk, OH; Tiffin, OH; and the surrounding areas, we are the smart choice when people want satisfying, scrumptious sweet popcorn. 

Visit us today, call us at (567) 283-5360, email us at [email protected], or contact us online. One bite, and we know that you will be a fan of Bay Popcorn Company, LLC, for life!  

Delectable Sweet Popcorn, Homemade with Love

Our sweet popcorn is incredible, delectable, and will take you back in time with every bite. Every flavor we offer at Bay Popcorn Company, LLC, is a family recipe, homemade with the love and care that comes from a family-owned and operated kitchen. Our made-to-order sweet popcorn is always fresh, and our customers visit us again and again because they just cannot get enough of the amazing taste. We mix our sweet popcorn with just the right amount of sugar and spice, making it a delight to every taste.

Our prices for our sweet popcorn and our butter popcorn are: 

Sweet Popcorn

Small, $6.50

Medium, $12.50

Large, $24


Small, $2.50

Medium, $5

Large, $10

Find Your Favorite Sweet Popcorn Flavor

We have a sweet popcorn flavor for every palate! Try them all to find your favorites:

Apple Jack
Bavarian Cream
Birthday Cake
Black Cherry
Blue Raspberry
Blueberry Cheesecake
Bourbon Beer
Bubble Gum
Carmel (Grandma B’s)
Carmel Apple

White cake flavored popcorn coated in sprinkles. Kids & party goer's favorite.

Buttery carmel you would think you were in heaven. Sweet & satisfying eating "Grandma B's" Secret Recipe.

A delectable combination of green apple and Grandma B's sweet smelling carmel. A true delightful duo.

Chicago Tri Mix
Cinnamon Apple
Coconut Cream Pie
Cotton Candy
English Toffee
Green Apple
Keoke Coffee

For your craving for sweet cinnamon we do a combo of vanilla and cinnamon cooked to perfection.

This is a coconut lover's dream come true. Starting with a sugary vanilla base and adding a fragrant coconut cream for a yummy taste treat.

Sweet and colorful made to satisfy SP.

Our English Toffee is a feast for your taste buds. A light carmel and toffee combination.

Lemon Pound Cake
Mint Chocolate Chip
Orange Cream 
Pina Colada 
Pralines & Cream 
Pumpkin Spice
Red Cherry
Red Cinnamon
Red White and Blue
Root Beer
Shamrock Shake
Sparkling Wine
Strawberry Cheesecake
Vanilla Butternut

Sophisticated flavorings worthy of top ingredients. A taste of smooth full-flavored white grape.

Make the flavor POP by adding contrasting sweetners, a combination of strawberry and cheesecake.

Movie night snack attack...The ultimate companion for movie night. The Vanilla Butternut will fit the bill.

New flavors coming! Our customers can special-order all of our flavors.

Strawberry Cheesecake

Carmel Apple


Chicago Tri-Mix



Green Apple


Birthday Cake


Available in tins.

No Sweet Tooth? No Problem

Bay Popcorn Company, LLC, is so much more than sweet popcorn, though. We have something for every taste, including savory popcorn, salty popcorn, and premium popcorn. No matter what kind of popcorn you like, we have it, freshly made from family recipes. We also offer gift baskets and corporate gifts, full of our delectable popcorn or mixed with nuts, pretzels, or candy. We are the smart choice for event popcorn, too. Bay Popcorn Company, LLC, can handle wedding gifts, popcorn for a birthday party or bridal shower, and much more. We can even match the color of the popcorn as closely as possible to the event’s colors. In Sandusky, OH; Fremont, OH; Norwalk, OH; and Tiffin, OH, we are the first name in popcorn! 

We can ship anywhere in the United States. No free shipping. Call us for details.

For updates and fun reads on the world of popcorn, check out our blog!